The Best Potato Salads (Plus the Sides I Always Bring With Them)

You know how there’s always that one bowl at a barbecue that people keep circling back to? That’s what I’m going for every single time. This roundup is my complete summer potluck game plan, starting with my three favorite potato salads, because yes, you absolutely need options. There’s the classic creamy version that’s been requested at every get-together I’ve ever hosted, the warm and tangy German-style that always catches people off guard in the best way, and a street corn twist that honestly shows off a little. But a great potato salad deserves great company, and that’s where the rest of this list comes in. I’m talking crunchy slaws, creamy make-ahead salads, and a few bright and fresh sides that balance everything out beautifully. Whether you’re feeding a backyard full of people or just trying to make sure there are leftovers, this is the lineup that never lets me down. Bookmark this one, you’ll be coming back to it all summer long.

1. Mom’s Creamy Potato Salad

This is THE potato salad. The one that disappears before anything else on the table. The dressing is perfectly creamy without being heavy, so every bite of potato, bacon, and egg actually shines. Make it ahead, let it chill, and get ready to hand out the recipe before the party’s even over.

View Recipe →

2. German Potato Salad

This one is totally different from your classic mayo-based potato salad, and that’s exactly why I love bringing it. A warm Dijon-vinegar dressing made with bacon grease gives it this rich, savory depth that people absolutely cannot stop eating. It’s the potluck curveball that wins every single time.

View Recipe →

3. Street Corn Potato Salad

If you love Mexican street corn and you love potato salad, this recipe is going to change your life a little. It’s creamy, smoky, and finished with cilantro, a squeeze of lime, and crumbled cotija so it doesn’t just show up to the party, it shows off. This is the bowl people keep accidentally standing next to.

View Recipe →

More Sides To Bring

Classic Coleslaw

Potato salad needs a crisp, tangy sidekick, and this classic slaw delivers every time. That satisfying crunch is the perfect contrast to soft, creamy potatoes, and it comes together so easily. Make it ahead so it’s cold and ready the moment the grill fires up.

View Recipe →

Bacon Broccoli Salad

Don’t be fooled by all the green, this salad gets gobbled up fast. Bacon, cheddar, and a creamy dressing make it feel right at home next to any potato salad spread, and even the kids go back for seconds. It’s also a fantastic make-ahead option when you want one less thing to worry about the day of.

View Recipe →

Easy Pea Salad

Creamy, crunchy, and always a crowd favorite. This pea salad earns its spot on the buffet table every summer. The peas keep it sweet and bright, while the bacon and cheddar make it every bit as satisfying as the potato salad sitting right next to it. Trust me, don’t underestimate the peas.

View Recipe →

Mexican Street Corn Salad

This is the perfect partner for my street corn potato salad, or the bold, creamy side that gives a classic potato salad plate some serious life. Cotija, chili powder, mayo, and a squeeze of lime make every single bite pop. It’s fast, flavorful, and completely party-ready.

View Recipe →

The Best Macaroni Salad

I don’t mean to brag, but this macaroni salad absolutely earns the title. It’s lighter on the mayo so all those other flavors actually come through. Bring this alongside potato salad to a barbecue and see which bowl comes back emptier.

View Recipe →

Italian Orzo Pasta Salad

When I want a potluck salad that feels a little extra without any extra effort, this is the one I reach for. The orzo stays perfectly al dente so there’s no soggy pasta situation, and the homemade vinaigrette is quick and so good. It’s a zippy, fresh contrast to all the creamy goodness on the table.

View Recipe →

Creamy Cucumber Salad with Garlic and Dill

This cool, creamy cucumber salad is exactly what a rich potato salad plate needs alongside it. The garlic and dill give it real flavor, but it still feels light and refreshing. Very much a summer side. It also tastes even better after a little time in the fridge, making it an ideal make-ahead.

View Recipe →

Spicy Sesame Coleslaw

I’m slightly obsessed with this slaw, and I think you will be too. The spicy sesame vinaigrette, fresh cilantro, and honey-roasted peanuts make it anything but boring. It’s bold, crunchy, and the perfect wake-up call next to a creamy potato salad. It’s the side that gets a double take every time.

View Recipe →

Easy Cucumber Salad

If you want something crisp and tangy to cut through the creaminess of potato salad, this is the move. It’s simple, refreshing, and has that classic pickled vibe from a handful of fresh dill and an easy vinaigrette. It practically begs to come to every picnic and potluck all summer long.

View Recipe →

Potato salad has a way of showing up at just about every warm-weather gathering, and I’m never mad about it. I hope this roundup gives you a few new favorites to bring to your next barbecue or potluck. Good food, good company, and a big scoop of potato salad is a pretty great combo.